A 90-day fuel-saving trial needs a comparable baseline, a comparison group and a decision rule agreed before you see the results. Measure verified litres and kilometres, then put the estimated saving next to the cost of the equipment and the work it adds.
Write the trial decision before day one
Specify which vehicles the trial covers, the change being tested and what qualifies as a usable comparison. Include only eligible, approved installations or operating changes. Set the minimum expected improvement, maximum acceptable cost, and the evidence required to make a confident rollout decision. Record those rules with the date and responsible reviewer.
Choose the metric for the work. For road vehicles, use L/100 km for comparable work and keep kilometres visible. For plant, litres per productive hour may be more useful where the hour data is trustworthy. Track fuel spend as a separate cost metric because the price per litre can move independently of consumption.
Use the 90 days to compare like with like
- Days 1–30. Collect a clean baseline. Match trial and comparison vehicles as closely as you can by class, route, payload pattern and duty cycle. Agree how drivers, maintenance and downtime will be logged.
- Days 31–75. Apply the change to the trial vehicles and keep recording both groups in the same way. Record the exact start date per vehicle and note any other changes, including tyres, routes, driver assignments or long periods of idling.
- Days 76–90. Verify the records and review results by vehicle and route group. Summarise exclusions and compare conclusions with and without any borderline intervals.
Use total litres divided by total kilometres
Calculate each group and period as 100 × total verified litres ÷ total verified kilometres. Use confirmed full-to-full intervals, or another consistently reconciled quantity measure when the source supports it. Review changes in coverage before interpreting the result. A missing receipt or a high-mileage vehicle dropping out can move the group average materially.
Worked example with a matched comparison group
The trial group moves from 12.0 to 11.5 L/100 km, a reduction of 0.5. The comparison group moves from 11.8 to 11.6 L/100 km, a reduction of 0.2 over the same period. The estimated change beyond the comparison group is 0.3 L/100 km. That is 2.5% of the trial group's baseline. It still depends on both groups experiencing comparable changes in work and operating conditions.
At 25,000 km per month, 0.3 L/100 km is 75 L. At an illustrative R23.50 per litre that is R1,762.50 in gross fuel savings. If the estimated monthly equipment and administration cost is R1,100, the illustrative net is R662.50 per month. Use your own observed price and costs. A savings threshold can be translated into required litres saved per month, which makes it easier to explain the decision to finance.
Decide which vehicles the evidence supports
Show baseline, trial results, comparison group and number of usable kilometres for each group. Mark changes in assignment and maintenance. Where a result rests on one vehicle or the groups changed jobs, record the limitation beside the estimate and decide whether to collect another comparable operating period. Check that the financial result still holds under the lower end of plausible savings.
Take the raw records, mapping sheet, exclusion register and worked calculation to the approval meeting. The guide to preparing fleet records gives a source checklist. The sample Fleet Exception Review shows how to document the coverage and evidence behind a decision.